Management

6 min read

Why 60% of New Managers Fail in Their First 2 Years (And How to Not Be One)

Why 60% of New Managers Fail in Their First 2 Years (And How to Not Be One)

The reasons new managers fail are specific, predictable and mostly fixable. Here are the six that matter, and what to do about each one this week.

Why 60% of new managers fail: Frontline Craft guide cover


You were good at your job. Really good. Good enough that someone decided the reward should be responsibility for other people doing that job.

Then you got the title, and within a few weeks you started to suspect nobody had actually told you how to do this.

You’re not imagining it. Research from CEB, now part of Gartner, is widely cited as putting the failure rate for new managers at roughly 60% within the first 24 months. “Failure” in that research is broad: it covers managers who underperform or don’t make it. In practice that means demoted, moved sideways, quietly managed out, or burned out and resigned.

That number gets thrown around a lot without anyone explaining why it’s so high. So let’s do that. Because the reasons are specific, predictable and, this is the useful part, mostly fixable if you know what you’re looking for.

First, what “failing” actually looks like

New managers rarely fail dramatically. There’s no single blow-up. It looks like this:

  • Your best team member resigns and you didn’t see it coming

  • You’re working longer hours than you did as an individual contributor, and producing less

  • Your one-on-ones have become status updates neither of you enjoys

  • Your boss has started checking in on things you thought were yours to own

  • You’ve quietly redone someone’s work at 10pm rather than have the conversation

None of those get you fired on their own. Stacked over eighteen months, they add up to a manager the organization stops betting on.

And the cost isn’t only yours. CEB research on leadership transitions found that the direct reports of a struggling leader perform about 15% worse than the reports of a high performer, and are about 20% more likely to disengage or leave. Your learning curve is being paid for by your team.

Reason 1: Nobody trained you, and probably won’t for another decade

This is the big one, and it’s structural rather than personal.

In a widely cited analysis of some 17,000 leaders, published by Jack Zenger in Harvard Business Review in 2012, people typically became supervisors around age 30, while the average age at their first formal leadership training was around 42. That’s roughly a decade of managing people before anyone teaches you how. It’s an older figure, but newer research points the same way: the Center for Creative Leadership found that almost 60% of first-time managers said they never received any training when they moved into the role.

Organizations promote for technical excellence and then assume management is something you’ll absorb. Most people absorb whatever their own manager modeled, good or bad.

What to do: Stop waiting for the company to train you. Managers who build the skills themselves, instead of waiting to be sent on a course, give themselves a much better shot at getting through the two-year window. A structured framework beats improvising under pressure.

Reason 2: You’re still doing the old job

The hardest transition in any career is going from the person who does the work to the person responsible for the work getting done.

The trap is that doing the work feels productive. It’s familiar, you’re fast at it, and it gives you a hit of competence at exactly the moment you feel least competent. So you keep taking pieces of it back.

Meanwhile the actual management work (clarity, feedback, prioritization, unblocking) doesn’t get done, because it never feels as urgent as the thing due Friday.

What to do: Audit your calendar for one week. Physically mark every hour as either doing or leading. As a rough rule of thumb, if more than 30% of your time is still doing, that’s your diagnosis. You don’t need more discipline; you need to delegate something specific this week.

Reason 3: You’re avoiding the conversation

Almost every new manager has one conversation they know they need to have and haven’t had. Underperformance. A bad attitude. Someone who used to be a peer and hasn’t adjusted.

The avoidance is understandable. You don’t have a script, and you’re worried about the relationship. But the cost compounds. The rest of the team sees the problem too, and they’re watching to see what you do about it. Every week you don’t act, your credibility drops a little further.

What to do: Write the conversation down before you have it. Opening line, the specific behavior (not the personality), the impact, the ask, the follow-up date. Most managers who dodge difficult conversations aren’t short on courage. They’re short on a structure. Get the structure and the courage becomes much cheaper.

Reason 4: You confused being liked with being trusted

New managers, especially ones promoted from within a team, often over-index on being approachable. Easy on deadlines. Reluctant to give corrective feedback. Quick to shield the team from every bit of pressure from above.

It feels like good leadership. It isn’t. Teams don’t trust managers who won’t tell them the truth. They trust managers who are consistent, clear and fair, even when the message is uncomfortable.

Gallup’s research finds that managers account for about 70% of the variance in team engagement scores across business units, and Gallup still cites that figure in its 2026 work. Pay, perks and the mission statement all matter, but most of the difference between teams comes down to the manager. That’s the size of the lever you’re holding, and you can’t pull it while trying to be everyone’s friend.

What to do: Pick one standard you’ve been letting slide and reset it openly this week. Explain the why. Apply it to yourself first.

Reason 5: You have no relationship upward

New managers focus almost entirely downward: their team, their team’s work, their team’s problems. Then they’re surprised when a decision gets made above them that undercuts everything they’ve built.

Managing upward isn’t politics. It’s making sure the person who allocates resources, headcount and air cover understands what your team is doing and why it matters.

What to do: Build a simple monthly update to your manager: what shipped, what’s at risk, what you need. Three bullets each. Do it consistently for six months and you’ll be in a much stronger position than peers who only surface when something’s on fire.

Reason 6: You’re treating overwhelm as a personal failing

Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace 2026 report found that manager engagement sat at 22% in 2025, down nine points since 2022, with the sharpest single-year drop between 2024 and 2025. Feeling stretched thin in this role is not a personal quirk. More often than not it comes down to workload and clarity rather than resilience: middle managers absorb pressure from above and below at the same time, and no amount of self-care fixes an unworkable structure.

What to do: Before you conclude you’re not cut out for this, get the workload visible. List every commitment you’re personally carrying, mark what only you can do, and take the rest to your manager as a prioritization conversation, not a complaint. “Here’s everything on my plate, here’s what I’d deprioritize, do you agree?” is a strong move, not a weak one.

The pattern underneath all six

Every reason on this list comes back to the same thing: new managers are handed a role with no operating system.

They’re given a title, a team, and a vague expectation to “step up.” Then they improvise for two years, and by the widely cited estimate, roughly six in ten don’t make it through.

The ones who do make it aren’t smarter or more naturally charismatic. They just got their hands on structure earlier (a way to run one-on-ones, a script for hard conversations, a delegation framework, a 90-day plan) instead of reinventing all of it under pressure.

Give yourself the manual nobody handed you

That’s exactly why we built the First-Time Manager Kit: a 59-page Playbook plus the editable scripts, forms and tracker you were supposed to be given on day one. Each of the six reasons above has a tool attached:

  • No training, no structure: a 30-60-90 day plan, plus a 90-Day tab in the Excel tracker to track your progress

  • Still doing the old job: a delegation sheet, a weekly priorities planner, one-on-one agendas and a Monday-to-Sunday capacity planner

  • Avoiding the conversation: 32 word-for-word scripts, each with a 60-second version, covering performance, conflict, workload and the shift from peer to boss

  • Liked vs. trusted: Performance & Standards scripts, plus a conversation record and a verbal warning record so standards are applied fairly and documented

  • No relationship upward: Managing Up & Sideways scripts for the conversations with your own boss and your peers

  • Treating overwhelm as failure: a 13-week scorecard in the Excel tracker so you can see the load, not just feel it

No theory. No 300-page leadership philosophy. Start with the Playbook for $17, grab the Script Library for $9, or get the Complete Kit with every editable file for $27.

Leading a team in a specific environment? There are role-specific kits too: Retail Shift Supervisor, Warehouse Team Lead, Call Centre Team Lead and Production Line Supervisor.

Sources

  • CEB (now part of Gartner): roughly 60% of new managers underperform or fail within 24 months, a figure widely cited, for example in Wharton Executive Education, “Why New Leaders Need Training” (2024). Direct reports of a struggling leader perform about 15% worse and are about 20% more likely to disengage or leave: CEB research on leadership transitions (2013), also cited by McKinsey (2018).

  • The training gap: Jack Zenger, “We Wait Too Long to Train Our Leaders,” Harvard Business Review (2012), based on Zenger Folkman’s database of roughly 17,000 leaders (average age at first formal leadership training around 42; people typically became supervisors around age 30). Center for Creative Leadership, “Developing New Managers? How to Set Your First-Time Leaders Up for Success” (2022): almost 60% of first-time managers said they never received any training when they moved into their first leadership role.

  • Gallup, “How Managers Impact Team Productivity” (updated November 2026): managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement. Gallup, State of the Global Workplace 2026: manager engagement 22% in 2025, down nine points since 2022, with the largest single-year drop between 2024 and 2025.